So what happened? Who were the winners and who were the losers? There’s only one clear winner today, and that’s John McCain. The man has all but stitched up the Republican nomination. Mitt Romney is the only clear loser today. As one man on CNN (who provided, by far, the best coverage of the day) put it “The only thing Mitt Romney can spin about today is that he’s got good hair.” That’s about all that Romney won. Mike Huckabee also came out ahead – streets further than I would have put him at – but it wasn’t enough to challenge the nomination. And, of course, Ron Paul plain old sucked. Really, I want to know where all those Internet people (also known as nerds) got off thinking that Paul had any real chance. While I said that he would be the best Republican candidate, I never for a moment thought he’d win the nomination.
The only murkiness that remains surrounds the Democrats. Neither Hillary Clinton nor Barack Obama have come out of this with any significant lead. Granted, the Obama campaign was never expecting to come out with a significant lead, but I can remember even a month ago that Clinton supporters were claiming she’d have the nomination in the bag by this hour. It must be disappointing for their campaign that she now finds herself in a rather tight race.
What the Clinton campaign will take hope from is the staying power of their candidate. As you read here, there was a late surge by Obama in polls everywhere. In places where Clinton wasn’t campaigning hard, that can be understood. But in places where she was supposed to win, that’s something that’s pretty rare. I had been saying for the past few days that if Super Tuesday actually was Super Friday, Obama would have won hands down. The momentum that he had over the last days of campaigning was huge, and as a results, if there was even two extra days, those surging poll numbers would have translated into actual votes.
Unfortunately, Obama didn’t pick up enough of the crucial states to make a real impact on Clinton. He needed any combination of two of these:
- Win/split the New York delegates;
- Win/split the Californian delegates;
- Win/split the Massachusetts delegates;
- Win/split the New Jersey delegates;
- Win/split the Connecticut delegates
Some of those, going by the polling numbers that were coming in, were very much on the cards. He pulled off a win in Connecticut, which was very welcome, but he needed another North-East state to show that it wasn’t a fluke. I’d be very disappointed in the Massachusetts Democrats – a state where he was endorsed by both Senators (Kennedy and Kerry) and the Governor, and he couldn’t get more than % of the vote. Splitting the vote here should have been an outcome. And California. And New Jersey. The polls pointed towards that as an outcome.
I wonder if the polls were premature or if they scared more Clinton supporters out to the streets. New Hampshire was like that – the Obama win in Iowa actually brought more Clinton supporters to the booths. It’s exactly the same as what will happen if she runs as the Democratic nominee – her presence scares Republicans out to the polls in droves. Either way, it looks like it happened in the pro-Clinton states this time around.
What is good is that Obama won more states than Clinton. This will feed the fires of electability. The argument has been raging, but has received less attention than the who race/sex debate on T.V. so far. The primaries should really be who is more electable. And, if that’s the judge, then from today’s performance, you’d say Obama, and give him the nomination. He won more mid-West states, has won as many Southern states in the whole race (and will likely win more than Clinton), he has snagged a couple of North-East states too. All-in-all, he has delivered in all the different parts of the U.S. at a better rate than Clinton.
However, the biggest disappointment, and probably the only legitimate one, is how he fared in California. I suspect the campaign was expecting a really tight race there so that he split the delegate count. If he had won it, then it would have been a whole new race. But that was never on the cards until the last polls came out. What was always expected was a close race. Closer than what was the outcome – 10% between the two (52% to 42%). A 5% or less difference would have been ideal; a win a dream. But it didn’t fall that way.
Obama’s big percentage wins in Alaska (75% to 25%), Utah (57% to 39%), Colorado (67% to 32%), Idaho (79% to 17%), Minnesota (67% to 32%), Kansas (74% to 26%), North Dakota (61% to 37%), Illinois (65% to 33%), and Georgia (67% to 31%) are what kept the big loss down. Obama has won significantly more delegates than Clinton across all of these, especially Illinois. These states kept his losses in the ‘big’ states to a reduced impact. Those ‘big’ states that Clinton won – California, New Jersey by 10%, Massachusetts by 15%, New York by 17%, Tennessee by 13% – might have hurt a lot more if those large percentage wins in the rest of the smaller states wasn’t so high or frequent. Similarly, those states where the two have split the vote (Connecticut, New Mexico, Missouri) have helped Obama stop any more of a lead that Clinton might establish. And finally, by picking up states that could have, had Clinton won them, created momentum for the opposition (Delaware, Alabama, New Mexico, Missouri), he has created momentum for himself, gained more delegates, and come out with an advantage.
So, to wrap this up. A week ago, if someone had shown me these results, and the end numbers, I would have been quite happy. I guess that when the polls started to suggest something miraculous, I should have been more wary. The day wasn’t an Obama sweep in terms of delegates. But thankfully, neither was it a sweep for Clinton either. And with more delegates to be factored in, though a current delegate count of 825 to Clinton and 732 to Obama (93 difference), I’d say that it was a very good day for Obama. Then remember that he won 13 states, possibly 14, and it turns into a fantastic day for him. Momentum and news cycles going into the next phase of the race. And that phase is in 3 days time, where Washington, Nebraska, and Louisiana vote for the Democrats. For the Republicans, it’s the same day, but Louisiana and Kansas. But John McCai, I suspect, won’t be worried. Though Clinton may very well be. The next few states are all favourable for Obama in terms of location, demographics, and delegates. The primary race for the Democrats is far from over. And it’s going to start up again tomorrow.
Thomas.
Recent Comments